Distraction Training For Dogs: Mastering the Art of Distraction by Building Engagement and Focus

Distraction Training for Dogs, By Will Bangura, M.S., CAB-ICB, CBCC-KA, CPDT-KIA, FFCP, (Certified Canine Behaviorist and Behavior Consultant)

Read-Time 20 to 30 Minutes.

In the bustling world we share with our canine companions, the ability to focus amidst chaos is not just a skill but a necessity for both safety and societal harmony. The journey of training a dog to navigate and respond reliably in distracting environments is both a challenge and a cornerstone of modern canine behavior training. This article delves deep into the foundational aspects of building a robust engagement between a pet parent and their dog, which is pivotal for achieving advanced obedience and effective distraction management. By fostering a strong relationship through structured engagement and play, pet parents can enhance their dog’s ability to concentrate and perform tasks reliably, no matter the level of external stimuli. We explore evidence-based strategies and progressive training methods that not only strengthen the bond between pet parent and dog but also equip our furry friends with the skills to face a world full of distractions with confidence and calm.

Keys to Distraction Training For Dogs: Engagement and Relationship Building

Importance of Engagement

Engagement between a pet parent and their dog is the cornerstone of effective training, particularly in managing distractions. The essence of engagement is the dog’s willingness to focus on the pet parent amidst external stimuli, which is fundamental for advanced obedience and distraction management. Studies indicate that dogs who are actively engaged with their handlers are more responsive and perform better in training tasks (McGowan et al., 2014).

Building Engagement

Engagement is not an inherent trait but a learned behavior that develops through consistent and positive interactions. The process involves clear communication, mutual trust, and understanding the dog’s motivations. Positive reinforcement techniques are essential, as they encourage dogs to choose to focus on their handler by making it rewarding to do so (Fernandes et al., 2017).

Play and Bonding

Role of Play in Training

Play is a powerful tool for building engagement and reinforcing desired behaviors. It serves multiple functions in a dog’s life, from mental stimulation to physical exercise, and most importantly, as a mechanism for strengthening the bond between dog and pet parent. Play allows handlers to create positive experiences in various environments, making the dog more adaptable and less reactive to distractions. According to Rooney and Bradshaw (2002), play with a pet parent can significantly enhance a dog’s responsiveness and obedience.

Integrating Play into Training

Incorporating play into training sessions can significantly increase a dog’s motivation and enjoyment, making learning more effective. Activities such as tug-of-war, fetch, and hide-and-seek with toys can be used as rewards during training sessions, providing both physical and mental challenges. These games should be structured so that the dog understands play is contingent upon following commands, which reinforces their obedience under distracting conditions (Horowitz, 2009).

Developing a Play Routine

Establishing a routine where play is a regular part of the dog’s day can help maintain high levels of engagement. This routine should vary the types of play to cater to the dog’s interests and energy levels, ensuring they remain focused and not bored. Consistent playtime also helps in managing a dog’s energy levels, making them less prone to distraction by external stimuli (Becker, 2014).

Eye Contact Games For Distraction Training For Dogs: Enhancing Focus and Communication

The Value of Eye Contact in Training

Eye contact is a fundamental aspect of dog training that fosters communication and enhances the bond between a pet parent and their dog. Training a dog to maintain eye contact helps in building focus and attention, which are crucial for effective training, especially in distracting environments. Eye contact games train the dog to look at the pet parent for cues, creating a pathway for more complex training sequences (Miklósi & Soproni, 2006).

Filtering Out Distractions through Games

Implementing Eye Contact Games Eye contact games should be introduced in a quiet and familiar environment to minimize distractions during the early stages of training. The goal is to make eye contact a positive and rewarding experience for the dog.

The Name Game

• Procedure: Sit in front of your dog and calmly say their name.
• Response: Reward the dog with a treat the moment they make eye contact.
• Progression: Gradually increase the duration of eye contact required before giving the reward.

The Look at Me Game

• Procedure: Hold a treat near your face and use a command such as “look at me”.
• Response: As soon as the dog looks at your eyes, verbally praise them and give the treat.
• Progression: Introduce mild distractions and increase the difficulty as the dog becomes more proficient at maintaining eye contact.

Advantages of Eye Contact

Eye contact not only improves the dog’s ability to focus but also enhances their responsiveness to commands. It establishes a non-verbal communication channel where the pet parent can guide the dog’s behavior effectively, particularly useful in high-distraction settings (Marshall-Pescini et al., 2009).

Application in Real-World Scenarios

Once a dog has mastered eye contact games in a controlled environment, these skills can be tested in more challenging scenarios. For instance, practicing these games in a park where other animals and people are present can help strengthen the dog’s ability to maintain focus amidst distractions.

Impulse Control Games For Distraction Training For Dogs: “Wait,” “Leave It,” and “Stay”

Importance of Impulse Control

Impulse control is crucial in ensuring a dog’s ability to resist distractions and follow commands, particularly in high-distraction environments. Dogs naturally react to stimuli like movement and scents, so teaching them to resist these impulses helps them focus on their handler and make conscious choices. Research shows that impulse control exercises can reduce the likelihood of unwanted behaviors and increase obedience (Bennett & Rohlf, 2007).

Implementing “Wait,” “Leave It,” and “Stay”

“Wait”

• Objective: Teach the dog to pause and remain still until given permission to proceed.
• Procedure:

• • Start with the dog on a leash in a low-distraction environment.
  • Give the command “wait,” holding your hand up as a signal.
  • Move forward a few steps while keeping the leash loose. If the dog stays still, reward with a treat.
  • Gradually increase the distance and duration before giving the release command.

• Progression: Introduce distractions by having someone walk by or using mild sounds, gradually building up to more significant distractions.

“Leave It”

• Objective: Train the dog to ignore objects or stimuli they are interested in.
• Procedure:

• • Hold a treat in your hand and allow the dog to sniff it. Firmly say “leave it” while closing your hand.
  • Once the dog stops sniffing and pulls away, reward with a different treat.
  • Increase the difficulty by placing the treat on the ground and covering it with your hand. Release the dog only when they look away from the treat.

• Progression: Add distractions such as toys or food on the ground in an outdoor setting. Practice while walking to simulate real-world scenarios.

“Stay”

• Objective: Teach the dog to hold a specific position until released.
• Procedure:

• • Command the dog to “sit” or “down” before giving the “stay” cue.
  • Take a step back and reward if the dog holds their position. Gradually increase the distance.
  • Introduce a release word like “okay” to let the dog know when to move.

• Progression: Practice with distractions like moving toys or other people and in various environments to strengthen reliability.

Impulse Control Games Benefits

Impulse control games help dogs learn to resist their natural urges and prioritize commands over distractions. These exercises can significantly reduce impulsive behaviors and improve a dog’s focus and ability to filter out distractions (Katz & Turner, 2013). For more information check out my extensive detailed guide on Impulse Control For Dogs

Focus Games For Distraction Training For Dogs: Nose-Touch Targets and Directional Cues

Importance of Focus Games

Focus games are essential tools to improve a dog’s attention span and responsiveness. By engaging the dog’s natural instincts through nose-touch targets or directional cues, pet parents can foster focus and teach their dog to prioritize commands over external distractions. Nose-targeting and directional training leverage dogs’ innate curiosity and problem-solving abilities (Feng et al., 2018).

Nose-Touch Targets

Nose-touch targets involve teaching the dog to touch a specific object or the pet parent’s hand with their nose on cue. This game capitalizes on the dog’s strong sense of smell and tactile exploration.

Hand Targeting

• Objective: Train the dog to touch the pet parent’s open palm with their nose on cue.
• Procedure:

• • Hold your open palm a few inches from the dog’s face and say, “touch.”
  • If the dog sniffs or touches your palm, mark the behavior with a clicker or verbal marker (“yes!”) and reward with a treat.
  • Gradually increase the distance and change the hand’s position (e.g., up, down, or to the side).
  • Introduce distractions or change environments as the dog becomes proficient.

• Benefits: Improves recall, focus, and provides an engaging alternative to verbal commands.

Target Stick Training

• Objective: Train the dog to touch a specific object, like a target stick or small ball.
• Procedure:

• • Hold the target stick or ball a few inches away and use a cue like “target.”
  • Mark and reward when the dog touches it with their nose.
  • Increase the difficulty by moving the target to different locations or varying the distance.

• Benefits: Enhances spatial awareness and teaches the dog to follow directional cues.

Directional Cues

Directional cues help a dog respond to commands indicating movement in a specific direction, useful in training focus during off-leash activities or agility courses.

Left/Right Commands

• Objective: Teach the dog to move to the left or right on cue.
• Procedure:

• • Start with the dog facing you and use a treat to lure them to the left or right.
  • Mark and reward once the dog moves in the correct direction.
  • Introduce verbal cues like “left” or “right” before luring.
  • Gradually reduce luring, allowing the dog to respond to the verbal cues alone.

• Benefits: Improves directional awareness and responsiveness.

Go-to-Place Commands

• Objective: Train the dog to go to a designated location, such as a mat or bed.
• Procedure:

• • Place a mat or bed a few feet away and encourage the dog to step onto it using a treat.
  • Use a verbal cue like “place” as the dog moves to the mat.
  • Mark and reward as soon as the dog steps onto the mat.
  • Gradually increase the distance and change locations to make it more challenging.

• Benefits: Helps in managing the dog’s movement and focus, especially in high-distraction environments.

Advantages of Focus Games

Focus games teach the dog to concentrate on the pet parent’s instructions despite external distractions, helping them become more reliable in obedience. These games also provide mental stimulation and reinforce positive interactions (Hall et al., 2018).

Progressive Training Plans For Distraction Training For Dogs

 Phase 1: Distraction Filtering at Home

Importance of Starting at Home

Home is a familiar environment where a dog feels secure and less overwhelmed, making it an ideal starting point for introducing distraction filtering. The goal of this phase is to build a foundation of obedience before gradually progressing to higher levels of distraction outside the home. Research shows that starting training in a low-distraction environment improves a dog’s learning and strengthens their behavioral response to future challenges (Deldalle & Gaunet, 2014).

Introducing Light Distractions at Home

In this initial phase, distractions should be kept light and easily manageable for the dog. The objective is to build the dog’s confidence in focusing on commands despite slight interruptions.

Favorite Treat Distraction

• Objective: Teach the dog to ignore a treat on the ground or in your hand until given permission.
• Procedure:

• • Sit or stand with your dog in front of you.
  • Place a high-value treat on the floor or hold it in your hand but do not offer it to the dog.
  • If the dog attempts to take the treat, firmly say “leave it” while covering the treat or closing your hand.
  • Mark and reward the dog with a different treat when they look away or step back.
  • Gradually increase the difficulty by placing treats further away or closer to the dog.

• Benefits: Builds impulse control and reinforces attention on the pet parent.

Favorite Toy Distraction

• Objective: Train the dog to stay focused on commands despite the presence of a beloved toy.
• Procedure:

• • Select a favorite toy and place it a short distance away from the dog.
  • Give the command “stay” while the dog is in a sitting or lying position.
  • If the dog attempts to move towards the toy, redirect them back to their position.
  • Mark and reward when the dog maintains their position despite the toy being present.
  • Increase difficulty by moving the toy closer or by tossing it gently.

• Benefits: Strengthens the “stay” command and reinforces focus on the pet parent’s voice.

Gradual Progression

Gradual progression is essential to avoid overwhelming the dog. Once the dog consistently responds well to commands in the presence of treats or toys at home, introduce slightly more challenging distractions. For instance, a family member walking through the room or a low-volume recording of barking can mimic outside stimuli. Increasing difficulty while maintaining a positive training experience helps build reliable responses (Hiby et al., 2004).

Advantages of Home-Based Filtering

Starting at home allows the dog to build the habit of filtering out distractions in a secure environment. This sets a strong foundation for more advanced phases of training outdoors or in unfamiliar settings (Lindsay, 2005).

Using Games to Reinforce Filtering Out Mild Stimuli

Importance of Filtering Out Mild Stimuli

Dogs are naturally curious and reactive to environmental changes. The ability to filter out mild stimuli, such as background noises or passing people, is a crucial skill that enhances obedience and reduces unwanted reactions. Games help create a positive learning experience, reinforcing the dog’s ability to focus while mild distractions are present (Pereira et al., 2016).

Implementing Filtering Games

Introducing mild stimuli at home or in controlled environments gradually helps a dog practice filtering out these distractions.

Remember The Name Recognition Game From Above?

• Objective: Reinforce responsiveness to the dog’s name while mild stimuli occur.
• Procedure:

• • Create a mild distraction like a soft toy rolling on the floor or gentle music playing in the background.
  • Call the dog’s name in a calm, upbeat tone and immediately reward with a treat if they make eye contact or come to you.
  • Increase difficulty by changing the type or level of mild stimuli, such as a bouncing ball or someone walking nearby.

• Benefits: Reinforces the dog’s ability to filter out distractions and respond promptly to their name.

Hide-and-Seek

• Objective: Encourage the dog to focus on locating the pet parent, even with mild distractions present.
• Procedure:

• • Have a family member or friend play light distractions (e.g., jingling keys, soft noises) while you find a hiding spot nearby.
  • Call your dog’s name to start the game, rewarding them with treats or toys when they find you.
  • Increase difficulty by hiding farther away or adding more distractions (e.g., low-volume TV).

• Benefits: Encourages the dog to prioritize finding the pet parent and ignore background noises.

Impulse-Control Tug-of-War

• Objective: Teach the dog to control their impulses and respond to commands during play.
• Procedure:

• • Initiate a tug-of-war game with a durable toy, ensuring the dog knows commands like “drop” or “give.”
  • Play the game but stop every so often, asking the dog to “drop” the toy. Reward them when they release it and give the cue to “take it” again.
  • Introduce mild stimuli, such as knocking on the door or rustling paper, and observe if the dog maintains focus on the game or command.

• Benefits: Strengthens impulse control and reinforces command following even when mild distractions are introduced.

Benefits of Filtering Games

Filtering games help dogs learn to prioritize their pet parent’s cues over mild distractions, fostering a foundation for focusing under more challenging conditions. They also encourage positive interactions between the pet parent and dog, helping maintain engagement and reducing training stress (Rooney & Bradshaw, 2002).

Phase 2: Medium-Distraction Training Outdoors

Importance of Medium-Distraction Training

Training in moderately distracting environments outdoors is a critical step toward building reliable behavior in real-world settings. Moving outside introduces stimuli like passing people, vehicles, and other animals, challenging the dog to maintain focus while practicing foundational behaviors on-leash (Hiby et al., 2004). This phase builds on the distraction filtering achieved at home.

Implementing Medium-Distraction Training For Dogs

Choosing a Suitable Training Environment

• Objective: Select a training location that introduces moderate distractions without overwhelming the dog.
• Guidelines:
  • Find a partially enclosed park, a quiet street, or an outdoor training field where the dog will be exposed to pedestrians, mild traffic sounds, and occasional animals.
  • Avoid areas with intense stimuli like large crowds or busy intersections.

On-Leash Training with Rewards

• Objective: Use a leash and high-value treats or toys to guide the dog through obedience exercises while maintaining focus on the pet parent.
• Procedure:
  • Eye Contact Games: Begin with eye contact games to reinforce engagement, offering rewards for consistent eye contact while gradually increasing distractions.
  • Recall Commands: Practice calling the dog from short distances, using an upbeat voice and rewarding promptly when the dog comes to you.
  • Loose-Leash Walking: Teach the dog to walk calmly by your side using cues like “let’s go” or “heel,” rewarding them for maintaining position and ignoring external distractions.
  • Impulse Control: Reinforce commands like “wait” or “leave it” when encountering mild stimuli like pedestrians or other dogs walking by.
• Progression:
  • Start with low to moderate distractions, such as a distant jogger or passing bicycle.
  • Gradually increase the intensity by training closer to mildly busy streets or parks where other dogs may be playing.

Incorporating Play into Training

• Objective: Use play as a reward to maintain engagement and build positive associations with training in outdoor settings.
• Procedure:
  • Bring a favorite toy and occasionally switch training tasks with a brief play session.
  • Use structured play games like fetch to reinforce recall or “drop it” commands.

Benefits of Medium-Distraction Training

Practicing outdoors under moderate distractions helps the dog develop confidence and reliability in responding to commands outside the home. This phase serves as a bridge between distraction filtering at home and more challenging real-world scenarios (Blackwell et al., 2008). Consistent reinforcement ensures that the dog views focusing on their pet parent as rewarding even with competing stimuli.

Gradually Introducing More Distraction Training For Dogs, Rewarding Engagement

Importance of Gradual Progression Gradually increasing the level of distractions is essential for a dog’s learning process. Introducing too many distractions too quickly can overwhelm them, leading to frustration and a breakdown in training. By steadily progressing to more challenging environments while continuing to reward positive engagement, the dog can build confidence and focus (Blackwell et al., 2008).

Implementing Gradual Introduction of Distractions

Planning Progressive Environments

• Objective: Develop a strategy for introducing progressively more challenging environments.
• Guidelines:

• • Moderate Distractions: Start with semi-enclosed parks or trails where dogs can be exposed to people jogging, cyclists, and other animals from a distance.
  • Higher-Level Distractions: Gradually move to locations where distractions are more unpredictable, like popular walking paths, dog-friendly beaches, or city parks.

Training with Increasing Distractions

• Objective: Use foundational commands and engagement games to maintain focus while gradually increasing distractions.
• Procedure:

• • Recall with Increasing Distance:

• • • Start with recall games in moderately distracting environments using high-value rewards.
    • Progressively increase the distance between you and the dog, ensuring that distractions are manageable but noticeable.

• • Loose-Leash Walking with Added Distractions:

• • • Practice loose-leash walking in busy streets or parks, rewarding engagement when the dog stays near your side despite stimuli.

• • Advanced Impulse Control:

• • • Reinforce “wait,” “leave it,” or “stay” commands in settings with other dogs or animals around.
    • Increase difficulty by placing desirable distractions, like toys or treats, and rewarding when the dog resists approaching them.

Rewarding Engagement

• Objective: Ensure consistent positive reinforcement for engagement, especially when distractions are present.
• Procedure:

• • Always mark and reward eye contact or immediate responsiveness to commands with treats or toys.
  • Gradually reduce the frequency of rewards as the dog becomes more reliable, providing praise as a substitute.

Benefits of Gradual Introduction of Distractions

Gradually introducing distractions while rewarding engagement ensures that the dog is not overwhelmed but steadily builds confidence in focusing on commands. The gradual progression builds a solid foundation, reducing the likelihood of reactivity or disobedience in highly distracting environments (Hiby et al., 2004).

Phase 3: High-Distraction Public Training

Importance of High-Distraction Training

Training in high-distraction public environments is crucial for preparing dogs to respond reliably to commands amid the most challenging situations. These settings may include bustling parks, popular trails, or areas where other animals and people are present. The use of leashes or long lines ensures safety while allowing the dog more freedom to explore. This phase builds on previous training to ensure the dog is well-prepared for the real world (Blackwell et al., 2008).

Implementing High-Distraction Training For Dogs

Choosing Appropriate High-Distraction Environments

• Objective: Select environments that challenge the dog while ensuring safety and manageability.
• Guidelines:

• • Busy public parks, dog-friendly beaches, and urban areas offer opportunities to practice in the presence of other dogs, people, and potential prey-like stimuli.
  • Ensure the location has enough space to work comfortably with a leash or long line.

Using Leashes or Long Lines for Control

• Objective: Maintain control over the dog while allowing for greater exploration and practice in high-distraction settings.
• Procedure:

• • Use a standard leash for close-range control or a long line (15-30 feet) for off-leash-like practice.
  • Start by practicing basic commands like “sit,” “stay,” and “come” at a short distance while distractions are visible but not overwhelming.
  • Gradually allow more freedom with the long line, but be prepared to redirect the dog if they become fixated on a distraction.

Training Exercises in High-Distraction Settings

• Objective: Reinforce foundational behaviors while ensuring the dog maintains focus and responsiveness.
• Procedure:

• • Recall Training: Practice recall commands using the long line, gradually increasing the distance and distractions. Reward promptly with high-value treats or toys.
  • Leave It and Stay Commands:

• • • Use “leave it” to reinforce ignoring distractions like other dogs or animals nearby.
    • Practice “stay” at a distance, rewarding the dog if they hold the position despite distractions.

• • Loose-Leash Walking:

• • • Walk the dog around other people or animals, rewarding with treats or toys when they remain focused on you.
    • If the dog pulls toward distractions, redirect them back to your side and reward when they re-engage.

Benefits of High-Distraction Public Training

High-distraction public training helps solidify a dog’s obedience and focus under the most challenging conditions. It ensures that the dog remains calm and responsive in public spaces, reducing unwanted behaviors like lunging, barking, or chasing. By practicing in these environments, dogs learn to associate positive outcomes with focusing on their pet parent even when distractions are significant (Hiby et al., 2004).

Gradually Reducing Leash Dependency as Reliability Improves

Importance of Reducing Leash Dependency

Transitioning from a leash to off-leash reliability ensures that dogs are responsive to commands even without physical control. However, this process must be approached gradually and methodically to maintain safety and effectiveness. As the dog’s reliability improves, reducing dependence on the leash is crucial for reinforcing obedience (Hiby et al., 2004).

Steps to Gradually Reduce Leash Dependency For Dogs

Assessing Reliability Before Reducing Leash Dependency

• Objective: Evaluate the dog’s responsiveness and focus before easing leash dependency.
• Guidelines:

• • The dog should reliably respond to foundational cues (recall, stay, leave it) in moderately distracting environments before reducing leash use.
  • Practice on a long line in areas with mild distractions to confirm consistent responses.

Transition to a Long Line

• Objective: Use a long line (15-30 feet) to give the dog freedom to explore while maintaining control.
• Procedure:

• • Begin training with foundational commands like “come,” “stay,” and “leave it” using a long line in moderately distracting environments.
  • Increase the distance between you and the dog, rewarding responsiveness promptly to reinforce engagement.
  • Gradually increase distractions (e.g., people passing by, other dogs) while ensuring the dog stays engaged with your cues.

Off-Leash Training in Controlled Environments

• Objective: Begin off-leash practice in safe, enclosed spaces with moderate distractions.
• Procedure:

• • Start in a fenced area, such as a backyard or training field, where the dog can practice off-leash without risks.
  • Reinforce foundational cues, using favorite treats or toys for rewards.
  • Gradually increase distractions, such as additional dogs or moving people, ensuring reliable responses.

Off-Leash Practice in High-Distraction Environments

• Objective: Practice off-leash commands in public spaces where distractions are significant.
• Procedure:

• • Choose large, fenced public parks or dog-friendly areas for the initial high-distraction practice.
  • Begin with close-range commands like “sit,” “stay,” and “leave it,” gradually increasing the distance and distractions.
  • Use a high-value toy or treat as a reward to ensure the dog remains engaged.

Benefits of Gradually Reducing Leash Dependency

Gradually reducing leash dependency while increasing distractions helps reinforce the dog’s focus on commands, even in real-world settings where leashes may not always be practical. By providing consistent positive reinforcement and gradual exposure, dogs can become reliable off-leash, which is essential for safe and enjoyable public outings (Blackwell et al., 2008).

Maintaining Reliability

Importance of Generalization Generalization is crucial to ensuring that your dog consistently follows commands in different environments, contexts, and situations. A dog’s ability to generalize obedience means they understand cues no matter the setting, whether at home, in a park, or on a city street. Generalization enhances reliability, reducing the chance of behavioral issues or reactivity (Friedman et al., 2009).

Strategies to Ensure Generalization In Distraction Training For Dogs

Practice Commands in Various Settings

• Objective: Familiarize the dog with obeying commands across a range of environments.
• Procedure:

• • Start by practicing foundational commands (sit, stay, come, leave it) in familiar, low-distraction settings.
  • Gradually introduce new environments like different rooms in the house, the backyard, or nearby parks.
  • Increase complexity by practicing in parking lots, busier parks, or public spaces.

Change the Context and Variables

• Objective: Test the dog’s understanding by altering the context in which commands are given.
• Procedure:

• • Vary your body posture or location, giving commands while sitting down, lying on the ground, or behind an obstacle.
  • Switch up the person giving the command, ensuring the dog responds equally well to multiple family members.
  • Alter the distance between you and the dog to ensure commands like “come” are understood from afar.

Gradually Increase Distractions

• Objective: Slowly raise the level of distractions to confirm generalization and reliability.
• Procedure:

• • Begin with mild distractions, like people or other dogs passing by, rewarding the dog for staying focused.
  • Introduce higher-level distractions, such as moving objects (balls, bikes) or animals (squirrels, birds).
  • If the dog becomes distracted, return to a lower level of difficulty before gradually working up again.

Reinforce Engagement Consistently

• Objective: Ensure continued reliability by consistently rewarding positive engagement, even as the dog becomes more reliable.
• Procedure:

• • Continue using high-value rewards (treats or toys) to reinforce focus in varied settings.
  • Provide verbal praise or physical affection to reinforce good behavior if treats are not available.
  • Use intermittent reinforcement to maintain motivation, varying the frequency of rewards to keep the dog engaged.

Benefits of Generalization for Maintaining Reliability

Practicing generalization helps dogs become adaptable to different environments and situations. This adaptability reduces behavioral issues and reactivity by ensuring that the dog understands and responds to commands no matter the distractions or new context (Blackwell et al., 2008).

Practice Regularly: Maintain Skills by Practicing Weekly in Different Settings

Importance of Regular Practice

Regular practice reinforces learned behaviors, preventing skill degradation and promoting consistency. Practicing weekly ensures dogs remain sharp and responsive to cues in diverse environments, regardless of distractions. It also reinforces the positive association between the pet parent and engaging in training (Hiby et al., 2004).

Strategies for Regular Practice

Schedule Weekly Training Sessions

• Objective: Set aside consistent training times to build and maintain your dog’s skills.
• Guidelines:

• • Designate at least two to three 10-15 minute sessions each week for training.
  • Choose a variety of settings to keep the sessions interesting and challenging, such as different rooms indoors, backyards, parks, or urban environments.

Vary the Training Environments

• Objective: Keep training fresh and stimulating by rotating through different environments.
• Procedure:

• • Indoor Settings:

• • • Practice in different rooms to ensure the dog can follow cues anywhere inside the home.
    • Vary the time of day to expose the dog to different lighting and noise levels.

• • Outdoor Settings:

• • • Alternate between familiar areas like the backyard and new locations like local parks or trails.
    • Incorporate urban environments, such as sidewalks or parking lots, to practice amid city sounds.

 Incorporate Foundational and New Commands

• Objective: Mix foundational commands with new ones to reinforce core behaviors and foster ongoing learning.
• Procedure:

• • Foundational Commands:

• • • Revisit basic commands like “sit,” “stay,” “come,” and “leave it” to ensure the dog responds promptly.
    • Gradually increase the complexity by introducing mild distractions or varying the cues’ distance and timing.

• • New Commands:

• • • Teach new commands to challenge the dog’s learning abilities.
    • Integrate new skills into foundational behaviors to keep the sessions varied.

Use Play as a Reward

• Objective: Reinforce positive training outcomes with playful activities.
• Procedure:

• • Conclude each session with a few minutes of play to maintain a positive association with training.
  • Use favorite toys, fetch, or tug-of-war to keep the dog motivated and looking forward to future sessions.

Benefits of Weekly Training Sessions Maintaining weekly training sessions helps dogs stay responsive and attentive, reducing behavioral issues that may arise from skill degradation. It also encourages continuous engagement and reinforces the bond between the dog and their pet parent through positive reinforcement and play (Blackwell et al., 2008).

Problems with Aversive Tools

Stress and Anxiety

Understanding the Impact of Aversive Tools on Canine Stress Levels

• Objective: Discuss the correlation between aversive training tools and increased stress in dogs.
• Details:

• • Studies have shown that dogs trained with aversive tools like shock collars, prong collars, and choke chains often display elevated stress signals, such as panting, yawning, lip licking, and tail tucking, during training (Arnott et al., 2014).
  • Aversive methods cause dogs to associate training with discomfort or pain, leading to an aversion to learning and reduced willingness to engage in commands or behaviors.
  • In a comparative study of dogs trained with positive reinforcement versus aversive methods, dogs in the aversive group showed more stress-related behaviors, while the positively reinforced group demonstrated increased engagement and reduced anxiety (Haverbeke et al., 2008).

How Stress Reduces Engagement and Focus

• Objective: Explain how stress interferes with a dog’s ability to focus and learn.
• Details:

• • Stress triggers a “fight or flight” response, causing the release of cortisol and adrenaline. These hormones can impair cognitive function, affecting memory and learning.
  • Anxious dogs are more likely to engage in displacement behaviors (e.g., excessive grooming, scratching) and avoidance behaviors (e.g., moving away, shutting down), making it challenging to achieve desired training outcomes (Rooney & Cowan, 2011).
  • In the long term, aversive methods can cause a dog to become fearful or aggressive towards the stimuli associated with punishment, increasing the likelihood of behavioral problems (Ziv, 2017).

Aversive Methods and Tools Are Ineffective for Long-Term Reliability

Diminishing Returns of Aversive Tools

• Objective: Examine the gradual loss of effectiveness in aversive training tools over time.
• Details:

• • Initial responses to aversive stimuli often involve a rapid compliance due to fear or discomfort, but this response becomes less effective over time as the dog becomes desensitized or develops learned helplessness (Overmier & Seligman, 1967).
  • Aversive tools can create an association between punishment and training contexts rather than correcting behaviors, leading to avoidance behaviors during training sessions instead of actual obedience (Blackwell et al., 2008).
  • Dogs often become more reactive or aggressive in the long term when exposed to frequent aversive corrections, particularly in high-distraction environments (Ziv, 2017).

Advantages of Positive Reinforcement over Aversive Methods

• Objective: Highlight the advantages of positive reinforcement for maintaining long-term reliability.
• Details:

• • Dogs trained with positive reinforcement are more engaged and motivated to follow commands, even in high-distraction environments, due to their association with rewards (Blackwell et al., 2008).
  • Positive reinforcement encourages the repetition of desirable behaviors by creating positive associations, which remain consistent and reliable over time.
  • Pet parents using positive methods are more likely to bond with their dogs, leading to better communication and cooperation throughout the training process (Rooney & Cowan, 2011).

Aversive tools not only increase stress and anxiety but also fail to provide lasting reliability in dog training. Positive reinforcement offers a more effective and humane approach that fosters engagement, strengthens bonds, and promotes long-term success.

Progressive Desensitization and Counterconditioning For Distraction Training For Dogs

Controlled Environment Training

Training in a Controlled Environment

• Objective: Establish a solid foundation for behavior by starting in a calm, familiar setting where the dog feels safe and is less likely to be distracted.
• Details:

• • Choose a location such as a quiet room in your home or a fenced backyard where external distractions are minimal.
  • Ensure the environment is free from sudden noises or movements that could divert the dog’s attention from training tasks.

Reinforcing Engagement with High-Value Rewards

• Objective: Encourage and reinforce the dog’s attention and responses to commands by using rewards that are highly appealing to them.
• Procedure:

• • Identify treats or toys that the dog finds most motivating. These can include special food treats (like small pieces of chicken or cheese) or favorite toys that are only available during training sessions.
  • Use these high-value rewards immediately after the dog successfully follows a command to reinforce the behavior.
  • Keep training sessions short and positive, typically around 5 to 10 minutes, to maintain high levels of engagement and prevent fatigue.

Introducing Light Distractions

• Objective: Gradually introduce mild distractions to teach the dog to maintain focus, preparing them for more challenging environments.
• Procedure:

• • Start with very low-level distractions, such as the sound of a TV at a low volume or a family member walking calmly in the room.
  • Command the dog to perform basic tasks (like ‘sit’, ‘stay’, or ‘look’) in the presence of these distractions.
  • If the dog successfully maintains focus and obeys the command, immediately reward them with a high-value treat.
  • Gradually increase the complexity of distractions as the dog shows consistent success. This might include increasing the volume of the TV, introducing more people into the room, or having someone gently toss a ball across the floor.
  • Always monitor the dog’s stress levels and reduce the distraction if it seems to be too overwhelming.

Benefits of Controlled Environment Training

• Advantages:

• • Builds confidence by allowing the dog to learn and succeed in a low-stress setting.
  • Strengthens the dog’s ability to focus on the pet parent, establishing a strong foundation for more advanced training.
  • Helps identify the dog’s threshold for distractions, which is critical for planning further desensitization steps.

For more in-depth detailed information visit our Counterconditioning and Desensitization Training Guide for Dogs.

The Right Way to Use Food for Focus and Engagement Without Using Food as a Bribe

Understanding the Difference Between Rewards and Bribes

Conceptual Difference

• Objective: Clarify the fundamental difference between a reward and a bribe.
• Details:

• • A reward is given after the desired behavior has been completed, reinforcing the behavior by creating a positive association.
  • A bribe is offered before a behavior to lure the dog into compliance, often leading to dependency on the visible treat.

Effects of Bribing on Learning

• Objective: Describe how bribing undermines focus and engagement.
• Details:

• • If a treat is always presented before a command is given, the dog may become fixated on the food rather than learning to perform the behavior in different contexts.
  • Dependency on visible treats makes training less reliable over time, particularly in high-distraction environments where a visible reward may not be as compelling (Smith & Davis, 2008).

Effective Use of Treats to Promote Focus and Engagement

Treat as a Secondary Reinforcer

• Objective: Train the dog to associate treats with commands, rather than as a primary motivation.
• Procedure:

• • Start with a high-value treat like cheese or chicken, providing it after the dog successfully completes a command.
  • Gradually pair the reward with verbal praise or a clicker to build a secondary reinforcer, which creates an expectation that praise or clicks lead to rewards.

Variable Reward Schedules

• Objective: Implement variable reinforcement schedules to maintain engagement without visible food.
• Procedure:

• • Initially reward every correct response to build strong associations between behavior and treat.
  • Once the behavior is reliable, switch to a variable schedule, rewarding only some responses. This keeps the dog motivated and attentive, as they cannot predict when a treat will come (Skinner, 1958).

Gradual Fading of Food Rewards

• Objective: Transition away from food as a primary reinforcement method.
• Procedure:

• • Gradually reduce the frequency of treats while increasing the use of secondary reinforcers like praise or play.
  • Maintain occasional food rewards to reinforce positive behavior, especially in high-distraction settings.

Importance of Treat Pouches to Avoid Bribing: The Role of Treat Pouches in Effective Training

Hands-Free Handling

• Objective: Keep treats accessible without needing to hold them.
• Details:

• • Treat pouches allow pet parents to focus on giving cues with hand signals or using a clicker while keeping food out of sight.
  • The pouch enables faster, consistent reinforcement delivery without the risk of the dog seeing the treat as a lure.

Preventing Bribery Dependency

• Objective: Avoid visible treats during training to prevent dependency.
• Details:

• • Dogs will associate the reward with completing the behavior rather than the initial cue, reducing reliance on visible treats to perform tasks.
  • Treat pouches ensure that food rewards can be accessed quickly for reinforcement without showing the treats before the behavior.

 Mild Public Distraction Training For Dogs

Practicing in Lightly Distracting Environments

• Objective: Gradually expose the dog to environments that offer more distractions than the controlled home setting, yet are not overwhelming.
• Details:

• • Choose locations like quiet parks, less trafficked streets, or public spaces during off-peak hours where distractions are present but not intense.
  • These environments might include distant pedestrians, occasional cyclists, or the mild noise of traffic, providing a moderate step up from the home environment.

Reinforcing Engagement and Focus

• Objective: Encourage the dog to maintain focus on the pet parent despite mild distractions.
• Procedure:

• • Continue using high-value rewards to reinforce attention. This reinforcement is crucial as distractions increase.
  • Utilize the “look” or attention cue frequently. When the dog looks at you, especially spontaneously in a distracting environment, immediately reward them.
  • Practice basic obedience commands like “sit,” “stay,” and “come.” Reward compliance enthusiastically to reinforce that following commands amidst distractions is beneficial and rewarding.

Techniques to Maintain Engagement

• Objective: Ensure that the dog remains engaged with the pet parent, not the distractions.
• Procedure:

• • Use a cheerful, engaging tone of voice to keep the dog’s attention. Dogs are very responsive to their pet parent’s tone and energy.
  • Incorporate movement into training sessions. Walking or changing directions can help keep the dog’s attention on you rather than on the environment.
  • Gradually extend the duration of attention and obedience exercises. Begin with brief moments of focus, gradually increasing the time as the dog’s ability improves.

Gradual Introduction of New Distractions

• Objective: Systematically introduce new distractions at a manageable pace to prevent overwhelming the dog.
• Procedure:

• • Start with one type of distraction, such as a person walking by at a distance. Once the dog is comfortable and can maintain focus, introduce another, like a person jogging.
  • Always observe the dog’s body language for signs of stress or discomfort. If any signs are noticed, reduce the level of distraction or increase the distance from it.
  • It’s essential to allow the dog to become accustomed to each new level of distraction before introducing more challenging ones.

Benefits of Training in Mild Public Distractions

• Advantages:

• • Helps the dog learn to filter out irrelevant stimuli, focusing instead on commands and cues from the pet parent.
  • Builds confidence and reliability in moderately challenging environments, which is essential for real-world obedience.
  • Prepares the dog for more intense training scenarios in a gradual, non-threatening manner.

Higher-Level Public Distraction Training For Dogs

Increasing Distractions with More Challenging Public Settings

• Objective: Prepare the dog to handle higher levels of distractions in real-world environments, including other animals, vehicles, and loud noises.
• Details:

• • Select environments like busy parks, urban streets, outdoor cafés, or dog-friendly events where distractions will be consistent and intense.
  • Ensure the dog has a foundational understanding of commands and attention cues before moving to these environments to avoid overwhelming them.

Implementing “Leave It” Cues and Favorite Rewards

• Objective: Reinforce the “leave it” cue to prevent the dog from reacting to distractions, maintaining focus on the pet parent.
• Procedure:

• • Use high-value treats or favorite toys as rewards for compliance. The reward should be more appealing than any surrounding distractions to hold the dog’s attention.
  • Begin with moderate distractions, such as people or dogs at a reasonable distance. Command “leave it” and reward the dog with a treat or play when they focus back on you.
  • Gradually close the distance to distractions while consistently rewarding desired behavior.
  • If the dog starts showing anxiety or losing focus, increase the distance or reduce the level of distraction until they can handle it successfully.

Reinforcing Desired Behavior in Short Training Bursts

• Objective: Keep training sessions concise and positive, helping the dog maintain focus.
• Procedure:

• • Practice commands like “sit,” “stay,” “look,” and “leave it” for brief intervals of around 5 to 10 minutes, then take breaks.
  • Allow the dog some time to relax, sniff, or engage with their surroundings between training bursts to keep the sessions enjoyable.
  • Gradually lengthen training bursts as the dog’s ability to focus and filter out distractions improves.

Managing Leash Dependency

• Objective: Encourage engagement and compliance without relying heavily on leash corrections.
• Procedure:

• • Start with a leash or long line for safety in high-distraction environments, using it as a backup rather than the primary tool.
  • Focus on voice commands and body cues, rewarding responses promptly to reduce the dog’s reliance on leash guidance.
  • Gradually work towards using a leash primarily for safety rather than correction as the dog’s reliability improves.

Benefits of High-Level Public Distraction Training

• Advantages:

• • Helps the dog remain calm and responsive in high-stress situations, reducing the risk of negative interactions with people or other animals.
  • Builds strong, reliable obedience that translates to everyday life, enhancing the dog’s safety and the pet parent’s peace of mind.
  • Develops the dog’s ability to filter out even highly enticing stimuli, resulting in a well-behaved, focused companion.

Using “Look at That” (LAT) Dog Training for Distraction Training

Overview of LAT Training “Look at That” (LAT) is a training technique designed to help dogs learn to handle distractions in a controlled manner. Initially developed by trainer Leslie McDevitt, LAT encourages dogs to look at a distraction (like another dog, a person, or a moving object) on cue and then look back at the handler for a reward. This method turns potential distractions into cues for a behavior that earns a treat, thereby changing the dog’s emotional response to the distraction.

Steps to Implement LAT Training

Introducing the LAT Cue

• Objective: Teach the dog to intentionally look at a distraction and then look back at the handler.
• Procedure:

• • Start in a low-distraction environment to introduce the concept.
  • Each time the dog notices a distraction (e.g., another dog), mark the moment they look at it with a clicker or a verbal marker like “yes.”
  • Immediately reward the dog with a treat. The timing is crucial—the reward must come right after the look and the marker.

Gradual Increase in Distraction Levels

• Objective: Practice LAT in progressively more challenging environments.
• Procedure:

• • As the dog becomes proficient at responding to the LAT cue in a controlled setting, gradually introduce more challenging distractions.
  • Increase the distraction level by moving closer to stimuli or practicing in busier environments, always ensuring the dog can succeed at each level before advancing.

Adding Duration and Distance

• Objective: Enhance the dog’s ability to maintain focus on the handler despite distractions.
• Procedure:

• • Begin to delay the reward slightly to encourage the dog to look back at the handler for longer periods.
  • Increase the distance from the distraction over time, reinforcing the dog’s ability to disengage from stimuli at greater distances.

Benefits of LAT Training

• Enhanced Focus and Control: LAT helps dogs learn to manage their reactions to distractions by focusing on the handler.
• Reduces Reactivity: By converting a potential trigger into a cue for a trained behavior, LAT reduces anxiety and reactivity, particularly in dogs with high prey drives or social anxieties.
• Builds Communication: LAT strengthens the communication bond between the dog and the handler, as it requires consistent interaction and mutual understanding to succeed.

Advanced Techniques and Situations

• Objective: Apply LAT training to more complex or challenging scenarios.
• Procedure:

• • Use LAT in dynamic environments such as dog parks, busy streets, or during travel.
  • Incorporate it into daily walks and routine outings to continually reinforce and maintain the behavior.

For pet parents and trainers seeking more detailed information on “Look at That” (LAT) training, including advanced tips and success stories, visit the detailed article on Look At That Dog Training.

Using Engage-Disengage for Distraction Training

Overview of Engage-Disengage Training Engage-Disengage is a training technique that helps dogs learn to manage their reactions to distractions by rewarding them for both focusing on and moving away from a trigger. This approach is particularly useful for dogs who struggle with anxiety, overexcitement, or aggression in the presence of certain stimuli. Engage-Disengage provides them with a structured way to assess and safely disengage from distractions.

Steps to Implement Engage-Disengage Training in Distraction Training For Dogs

Introducing the Engage-Disengage Cue

• Objective: Teach the dog to look at a trigger and then voluntarily disengage.
• Procedure:

• • Start in a controlled environment with mild distractions. Identify a known trigger (e.g., another dog or moving vehicle) at a distance where the dog can see it but not become overly excited or anxious.
  • Mark and reward when the dog looks at the trigger (“engage”), then immediately encourage them to turn back to you (“disengage”) for another reward.
  • Repeat this process several times, maintaining a calm demeanor. This positive reinforcement will help the dog form a positive association with the trigger.

Gradually Increasing Complexity

• Objective: Enhance the dog’s ability to voluntarily disengage from distractions.
• Procedure:

• • As the dog becomes proficient in low-distraction environments, introduce the Engage-Disengage exercise in more challenging settings.
  • Practice around greater distractions, such as other dogs in public areas, noisy environments, or wildlife. Ensure that the distance to the trigger allows the dog to remain calm and successfully disengage.
  • Gradually decrease the distance to the trigger while still rewarding the dog for looking and turning away.

Adding Duration to Disengagement

• Objective: Build a stronger disengagement response from the dog.
• Procedure:

• • Extend the amount of time the dog focuses on the handler after disengaging from the trigger.
  • Encourage the dog to follow the handler’s movements or commands, rewarding them for maintaining focus away from the distraction.
  • As the dog’s ability to stay engaged increases, provide consistent rewards to reinforce this behavior.

Benefits of Engage-Disengage Training

• Self-Control: The technique encourages dogs to develop better self-control by providing a structured response to distractions.
• Reduced Anxiety or Overexcitement: Repeatedly rewarding disengagement helps reduce anxiety and overexcitement over time.
• Reinforced Focus: Engage-Disengage strengthens the bond between the dog and the handler by building clear communication and mutual trust.

Advanced Techniques and Real-World Application

• Objective: Apply the Engage-Disengage method in more diverse and challenging scenarios.
• Procedure:

• • Practice Engage-Disengage in locations like dog parks, outdoor events, or bustling neighborhoods.
  • Integrate this exercise into daily routines to maintain the dog’s consistent focus and calm behavior.

To delve deeper into the details of teaching Engage-Disengage and how this method can be adapted for various distraction training scenarios, explore the full article at Engage Disengage Training for Dogs.

The Right Way to Use Food in Dog Training

Overview of Using Food in Dog Training Food rewards are powerful reinforcers in dog training, motivating dogs to learn new behaviors and practice them consistently. When used correctly, food can enhance focus, engagement, and reliability. The key lies in understanding how to integrate food into training without it becoming a bribe.

Steps for Properly Using Food in Training

Avoiding Food Bribes

• Objective: Prevent food from being used as a bribe, where the dog only responds when food is visible.
• Procedure:

• • Begin by rewarding desired behaviors promptly, but keep treats out of sight until the behavior is complete.
  • Use a treat pouch or a pocket to keep treats accessible yet hidden.
  • Gradually reduce the reliance on visible rewards by occasionally using non-food rewards like praise or a toy after the desired behavior.

Timing Rewards

• Objective: Ensure food rewards reinforce specific behaviors effectively.
• Procedure:

• • Mark the desired behavior with a clicker or a verbal marker like “yes.”
  • Deliver the food reward promptly, within a few seconds of the marked behavior, to establish a clear association.
  • Practice rewarding behaviors with high value and low-value treats, gradually varying the reward value to reinforce consistency.

Gradual Reduction of Food Rewards

• Objective: Transition away from food as the sole reward over time.
• Procedure:

• • Begin by rewarding every successful behavior with food, then slowly transition to a variable schedule.
  • Replace some food rewards with verbal praise, toys, or play.
  • Introduce more challenging tasks to reinforce that focus and good behavior lead to variable rewards.

Benefits of Using Food Correctly

• Enhanced Focus and Learning: Food engages the dog’s attention and helps them learn faster, reinforcing a positive association with training.
• Reduced Reliance on Treats: Proper training with food ensures that dogs listen to commands even when rewards aren’t visible or immediately given.
• Strong Communication Bond: The effective use of food encourages communication between the pet parent and the dog, fostering mutual trust.

Advanced Techniques and Considerations

• Objective: Maximize the benefits of food rewards in different training contexts.
• Procedure:

• • Adjust treat types and quantities based on the dog’s preferences, age, and dietary needs.
  • Consider training environments carefully to match the reward to the level of distraction present.
  • Continue refining timing and reward patterns as the dog progresses.

For comprehensive insights and strategies on using food in dog training, including managing treat dependency and transitioning to variable rewards, read the full article on The Correct Way to Use Food Rewards in Dog Training.

Summary and Conclusion

This article emphasizes the crucial role of developing a deep bond between pet parents and their dogs as a foundational step in distraction training. The initial sections address the importance of engagement, which is defined as the dog’s consistent focus on the pet parent amidst distractions. It is highlighted as the essence of effective training, necessary for advanced obedience and managing distractions. Through positive reinforcement and strategic play, pet parents can significantly enhance their dog’s responsiveness and obedience. The article outlines methods such as eye contact games, impulse control exercises, and focus games, all designed to improve the dog’s attention and responsiveness.

Additionally, the progression through various training phases—from controlled environments at home to more challenging public settings—is detailed to show how gradually increasing distractions can help dogs learn to maintain focus and composure. The use of “Look at That” (LAT) training and the Engage-Disengage method is discussed as advanced techniques to help dogs handle distractions in a controlled manner. The role of play in training is underscored as a vital element for mental stimulation and physical exercise, which aids in strengthening the bond and improving a dog’s adaptability to distractions.

Training a dog to be attentive and obedient in the face of distractions is a gradual process that requires patience, consistency, and a clear understanding of the dog’s behavioral cues. The strategic building of engagement through trust, communication, and mutual enjoyment forms the bedrock of successful training. As pet parents navigate the complexities of modern environments, equipping their dogs with the skills to handle distractions not only enhances the quality of their mutual experiences but also contributes to the overall well-being and safety of both the dog and the community. Ultimately, the principles of engagement and relationship building, combined with consistent practice and positive reinforcement, empower dogs to achieve their full potential as compliant and reliable companions. This journey not only fosters a profound bond but also ensures that both pet parent and dog can confidently navigate the distractions of the world with ease and assurance.

References

• Arnott, E. R., Early, J. B., Wade, C. M., & McGreevy, P. D. (2014). Environmental factors associated with success rates of Australian stock herding dogs. PLoS ONE, 9(8), e104457.

• Becker, M. (2014). Why play is important for your dog’s health. Retrieved from vetstreet.com.

• Bennett, P. C., & Rohlf, V. I. (2007). Owner-companion dog interactions: relationships between demographic variables, potentially problematic behaviors, training engagement, and shared activities. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 102(1-2), 65-84.

• Blackwell, E. J., Twells, C., Seawright, A., & Casey, R. A. (2008). The relationship between training methods and the occurrence of behavior problems, as reported by owners, in a population of domestic dogs. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research, 3(5), 207-217.

• Deldalle, S., & Gaunet, F. (2014). Effects of two training methods on stress-related behaviors of the dog (Canis familiaris) and on the dog–owner relationship. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research, 9(2), 58-65.

• Fernandes, J. G., Olsson, I. A. S., & Vieira de Castro, A. C. (2017). Do aversive-based training methods actually compromise dog welfare?: A literature review. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 196, 1-12.

• Friedman, S. G., Klein, L., & Grant, R. K. (2009). Generalization gradients in domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) under varied conditions of reinforcement. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research, 4(2), 57-58.

• Haverbeke, A., Laporte, B., Depiereux, E., Giffroy, J. M., & Diederich, C. (2008). Training methods of military dog handlers and their effects on the team’s performances. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 113(1-3), 110-122.

• Hiby, E. F., Rooney, N. J., & Bradshaw, J. W. S. (2004). Dog training methods: their use, effectiveness and interaction with behaviour and welfare. Animal Welfare, 13(1), 63-69.

• Horowitz, A. (2009). Inside of a dog: What dogs see, smell, and know. New York, NY: Scribner.

• Katz, M., & Turner, D. (2013). Impulse control training for dogs. Retrieved from ASPCA.

• Lindsay, S. R. (2005). Handbook of applied dog behavior and training, volume three: Procedures and protocols. Ames, IA: Blackwell Publishing.

• Marshall-Pescini, S., Valsecchi, P., Petak, I., Accorsi, P. A., & Previde, E. P. (2009). Does training make you smarter? The effects of training on dogs’ performance in a problem-solving task. Behavioural Processes, 81(3), 449-454.

• McGowan, R. T. S., Rehn, T., Norling, Y., & Keeling, L. J. (2014). Positive affect and learning: exploring the “Eureka Effect” in dogs. Animal Cognition, 17(3), 577-587.

• Miklósi, Á., & Soproni, K. (2006). A comparative analysis of animals’ understanding of the human pointing gesture. Animal Cognition, 9(2), 81-93.

• Overmier, J. B., & Seligman, M. E. (1967). Effects of inescapable shock upon subsequent escape and avoidance responding. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 63(1), 28-33.

• Pereira, J. S., Fragoso, S., Pires, E., Calado, L., Pereira, T., & De Sousa, L. (2016). Comparison of how owner’s perceived knowledge and actual knowledge relate to practices regarding dogs. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 12, 20-27.
• Rooney, N. J., & Bradshaw, J. W. (2002). An experimental study of the effects of play upon the dog–human relationship. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 75(2), 161-176.

• Rooney, N. J., & Cowan, S. (2011). Training methods and owner–dog interactions: Links with dog behaviour and learning ability. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 132(3-4), 169-177.

• Skinner, B. F. (1958). Teaching machines. Science, 128(3330), 969-977.
• Smith, B. P., & Davis, H. (2008). An examination of the efficacy of clicker training for improving response to basic commands in shelter dogs. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 11(3), 207-216.

• Ziv, G. (2017). The effects of using aversive training methods in dogs—A review. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research, 19, 50-60.